The medium flat-rate box came to more than Genevieve Martel expected, and Carol Ann Petty, who had run the window at the Seneca Quay post office for most of her life, would not take her money until she knew what was inside it.
"Patterns," Genna said. "Elspeth's duplicates. The quilt guild over in Penn Yan keeps a lending library, and they asked for them."
"Duplicates." Carol Ann turned the word over like a postmark. "Honey, Elspeth Finch didn't own two of anything. That woman put labels on her labels."
"She had four copies of the same issue from 1979. I checked."
Carol Ann pressed the label flat with the heel of her hand, then looked up, recognition arriving a beat late. "Well. You're Elspeth's girl. The one from Philadelphia."
"Genevieve Martel." Genna laid her bank card on the counter. "I'm settling the estate."
"I know who you are. Mabel Henderson has told the whole town you've been going through that house room by room." The card reader beeped, and Carol Ann tore the receipt free. "Elspeth never threw out a receipt in her life. Somebody ought to read them."
"That's part of why I'm here."
"Then ask me something." Carol Ann folded her arms on the counter. "It's Monday, and on Mondays nothing happens in this town except water bills."
The post office took up a narrow storefront on Main Street, between the insurance office and the bank, with one service window and a corkboard crowded with the Founder's Day flyer, a lost-cat notice, and a hand-lettered card for the bake sale. Outside, the fog had not lifted off the lake, and the flag over the door hung limp with damp.
"Box 118," Carol Ann said when Genna asked. "She rented it better than forty years. The last time she came in, she paid two years ahead. I told her that was optimistic. She told me it was just good bookkeeping."
"Her papers thin out after 1994. I found a folder of tax receipts in a drawer with nothing behind it, and I've been trying to work out where the rest of it went."
The bell over the door rang. Mabel Henderson came in with a birthday card in one hand and a wool scarf wrapped twice around her neck.
"Genna. You're the second person today to tell me it's Monday."
"It is Monday," Carol Ann said. "It'll rain by noon. My knees filed a complaint an hour ago."
"Six stamps, please." Mabel counted bills against the glass. "My granddaughter turns nine on Thursday. In Rochester. Nine years old, and she asked me for a dictionary."
"From you?" Genna said.
"From her own head." Mabel tucked the stamps into her purse. "I have to stop at the Tops in Geneva on the way home and see if the cream is on sale."
"One thing before you go." Genna turned on the stool. "Did Elspeth ever mail her quilts anywhere? A show, a shop, a museum?"
Mabel stopped with her purse half closed. "Lord, no. She wouldn't let one cross the county line. She said a quilt ought to stay where people could sit under it."
"Well." Carol Ann slid a book of stamps across the counter. "That's Elspeth for you."
Mabel said her goodbyes and went out. The bell rang twice, once for her and once for the draft.
"Raffle tickets," Carol Ann said. "Queen-size, and the whole committee pieced it. One dollar, six for five. If you're still in town for Founder's Day, that quilt is worth a look."
Genna checked the clock above the window. David was meeting her at the historical society at ten to pull the old Gazette negatives, so she had time. "I'll keep it in mind."
Carol Ann leaned her elbows on the counter. The lobby was empty.
"You're not going to believe this," she said, "but I have been waiting a week for you to walk through that door."
"Why?"
"Because you're asking the right questions, and not one person in this town is answering them."
Genna said nothing. It worked better than prompting.
"Not three days after Julian Croft's boat came back empty, Elspeth Finch came through that door with a box." Carol Ann dropped her voice another notch. "Brown paper. Twine. Taped, and then taped again. I put it on the scale twice because I thought the thing had stuck."
"How big was it?"
"Bigger than a hatbox. Heavier than a case of wine. I said, Elspeth, what have you got in there, rocks?"
"What did she say?"
"She said, 'Something that needs to go.'"
Genna took the receipt from the counter and folded it twice. Elspeth had documented forty years of ordinary living: receipts in labeled folders, letters answered the day they arrived, a journal of stitches kept in her own hand. None of that suggested a woman who improvised.
"Where did it go?"
"Arizona."
"Do you remember the town?"
"Something little. I remember standing right here thinking, who do we know in Arizona? Nobody. Not a soul in Seneca Quay had people out there, and I would have handled that mail."
"Do you remember the name on the label?"
"Finch. Elspeth Finch, in her own hand. She crossed her sevens." Carol Ann straightened. "She paid cash. I asked her if it was family, and she said it was a family matter, and that was the whole conversation."
"Was there a return address?"
"Same hand, same ink. 12 Elm Street." Carol Ann tapped the counter. "That's how I knew it was her sending it and not somebody using her name."
Genna turned the fact over the way she turned a seam, wrong side first. A box that heavy, sealed twice, paid for in cash, mailed out of a town in the middle of its worst week in thirty years, sent to a state where Elspeth knew no one. It did not fit grief. It did not fit errands.
"Did anything ever come back? A reply, a return, a forwarding notice?"
"Not one thing." Carol Ann glanced at the door, then back at her, and her voice went soft the way people's do when they have decided to say a thing out loud. "I never saw a letter come back from that address, not ever. It was like she just mailed a box of secrets off into the desert."
Comments
Loading the conversation…