Nora Vance gripped the strap of her canvas bag, the Agnes Miller diary tucked safely inside. She stepped into the polished hall of the Port Blossom Historical Society, ready to present evidence that could upend a local legend. The potential loss was considerable: Judith Finch’s family legacy, painstakingly preserved for generations, might be exposed as a cover for Prohibition-era smuggling.
The building, a sturdy Greek Revival structure, smelled faintly of old paper and beeswax polish. A volunteer pointed Nora towards Judith Finch’s office down a quiet corridor. Judith, President of the Society and great-grandniece of the celebrated Captain Alistair Finch, sat behind a large mahogany desk, surrounded by framed portraits of stern-faced ancestors. A glass cloche on her desk protected a miniature sailing ship model, the *Gannet*, from dust.
"Mrs. Vance," Judith said, rising with a composed smile. "Do come in. I wasn't expecting you quite so soon after our last discussion."
Nora offered a polite nod. "Good morning, Mrs. Finch. Thank you for making time. I've uncovered something during my work on the cottage that I believe might be of historical interest."
She took the small, leather-bound diary from her bag, placing it carefully on the corner of the desk, not near the ship model. "This belonged to Agnes Miller, the lighthouse keeper's wife from the 1920s."
Judith picked up the diary, her brow furrowing slightly as she turned it over in her hands. "Agnes Miller? My, that's a name I haven't heard in ages. A rather lonely woman, I recall. Her husband, Harold, lost the light, didn't he? A bit of a scandal at the time, though the official records are, shall we say, rather sparse on details." She offered a thin, knowing smile.
"Indeed," Nora replied. "It seems Mrs. Miller chronicled more than just the weather. Some of her entries from 1923 describe rather unusual activity around Tern Island during Prohibition." Nora watched Judith's face closely. "Specifically, late-night visitors and mentions of 'crates of medicine' being brought ashore by Captain Finch's sloop, the *Gannet*, and a Blackwood trawler."
Judith’s smile remained fixed, but a tension hardened her posture. She laid the diary down with a precise movement. "Well, Mrs. Vance, it was a different time, wasn't it? Laws were... interpreted. People found ways to make a living. And lonely women, particularly those living in remote lighthouses, often had overly active imaginations."
"The entries are quite detailed," Nora pressed gently. "She mentions specific dates, the names of the vessels, even a 'terrible argument' between the partners."
"Gossip, Mrs. Vance. Idle chatter, nothing more." Judith waved a dismissive hand. "The town's history is well-documented. My great-granduncle, Captain Alistair Finch, was a patriot. He provided essential goods to the community during a period of great economic hardship. His reputation is beyond reproach." She folded her hands on the desk, her expression now rigid.
"I also found discrepancies in the harbor master's ledgers from that period," Nora continued, recalling the heavy draft marks listed against light cargo. "For the *Gannet*, specifically. Nine voyages in late 1921. The listed cargo didn't match the indicated weight."
Judith scoffed softly. "Clerical errors, no doubt. Commonplace in those days. Or perhaps a more practical explanation: Captain Finch was known for his innovative methods. One simply must remember the context of the era." She paused, her eyes narrowing slightly. "Are you suggesting my great-granduncle, a pillar of this community, was involved in something… untoward? Based on a lonely woman's scribblings and misfiled numbers?"
"I'm merely presenting what I've found," Nora said, her voice even. "As an architect, I look at the structural integrity, the underlying truth. These seem to point to a different narrative than the official one."
"The official narrative is quite sufficient," Judith countered, her voice now colder, sharper. "Captain Finch risked his life to keep Port Blossom supplied. He built that cottage with his own hands, a symbol of his dedication to this town. My family suffered greatly when he was lost at sea. To cast aspersions now, so many decades later, is simply irresponsible."
Nora picked up the diary, sensing the conversation had reached a wall. "I understand. I just thought, given your position here, you might appreciate seeing all historical accounts, even the unofficial ones."
"Some accounts are best left to gather dust on a shelf," Judith replied, leaning back in her chair. "Especially when they threaten to undermine the efforts of those who truly preserved our heritage." She gestured around the office, to the portraits and the meticulously cataloged shelves. "The Historical Society works tirelessly to ensure the proper history of Port Blossom is maintained. A donation of fifty dollars helps us care for precious artifacts."
"Of course," Nora said, retrieving her bag. She pulled out her wallet and counted out a twenty and three ten-dollar bills from the cash she kept for small purchases at the Chart & Compass diner. "Here you are."
Judith accepted the money without looking at it, her gaze fixed on Nora. "Thank you. Now, if you'll excuse me, I have a meeting with the Mayor regarding the Founder's Day Regatta. A truly important event, unlike fanciful stories."
Nora stood, her attempt to share information met with outright dismissal and veiled hostility. She recognized the determined gleam in Judith’s eyes. It was a clear warning.
"Thank you for your time, Mrs. Finch," Nora said, turning towards the door.
"Mrs. Vance," Judith called out, stopping Nora with the quiet tone. Nora turned back. Judith stood, her hands resting on the mahogany desk, her expression perfectly serene once more. "Some histories are best left undisturbed, Mrs. Vance. It protects everyone involved."
Comments
Loading the conversation…