Mariah Blackwood-Cates was standing on the porch when Eleanor came up the walk with the mail in one hand and the water bill in the other. She had brought a plate, cheese straws under foil, still warm enough to fog the underside.
"I hope you'll forgive me for arriving without calling," Mariah said. "I know it's early."
"It's twenty past eight and the coffee's already made. Come in." Eleanor caught the storm door with her elbow and held it.
In Eleanor's kitchen on Poplar Street, Mariah set the plate on the counter, between the Food Lion circular and the rolled photocopy of the 1993 Blackwood survey that had not left that counter since the last week of October.
"Uncle Silas telephoned me last night," she said. "He told me you've been asking questions all over town about my father. The courthouse. Miss Lillian, out at the assisted living center. Caleb Hale's farm." She smoothed the foil flat with two fingers. "He said you've been asking about the fifty acres."
"I've been asking about the county's own maps," Eleanor said. "The fifty acres is what the maps say."
"Eleanor, I'm asking you to stop."
There it was, set down as neatly as the plate. Outside, the last red maples on Poplar Street were letting go a leaf at a time. Eleanor filled two cups and did not answer yet.
"May I ask you something first?"
"Anything."
"Last night on the phone. Did your uncle ask you to come here, or did you offer?"
Mariah's hands stayed wrapped around the cup. "He was worried about you. He said the whole town was talking, and that it would come back on the Society, and on me." She drank. "Does it matter who asked?"
"It matters to me."
Mariah set her cup down. "Your uncle mentioned Caleb Hale. Do you know him?"
"I know his letters." Mariah folded her napkin in half. "Mr. Hale has written to the Historical Society every spring for thirty years about that oak stump on the western line. Three pages, single-spaced, with a hand-drawn map of the same few yards of ground. My mother used to say he spent more on postage than the stump was worth."
"And the boundary he says is wrong?"
"The boundary moved when the creek moved. That's what the flood did to this valley. It took the Sturgill barn and the mill wheel, and it took a good piece of bank off the Hale line. Nobody argues with a creek."
Eleanor let that sit. Thirty years of signed, mailed, filed-in-a-public-reading-room letters. A man with a murder on his conscience does not write three pages every spring and put his return address on the envelope.
"Tell me about your father."
Mariah talked for a while. Thomas Blackwood had taught her to bait a hook before she could read a calendar. He kept his survey stakes in a coffee can in the barn, and when he walked the lines he made her carry the notebook and read the bearings back to him.
"He swam that creek the way other men walk out to the mailbox," Mariah said. "But the water was over the road at the Sturgill place that night, and still rising. Nobody swims that."
Nobody does. Eleanor turned her cup a quarter turn on its saucer and said nothing.
"They couldn't bury him for six days. The ground was too wet for the sexton to dig. I was twenty-two and three hundred miles away in Chapel Hill, and by the time I got home, everything that needed deciding had already been decided."
"Who decided?"
"Uncle Silas." Mariah said it easily. "He has a head for paper. The funeral, the probate, the taxes, all of it. He has never once asked any of us for thanks."
"The survey that came after the flood. Do you know who drew it?"
"Someone out of Asheville, I believe. Uncle Silas would know. He kept all of it."
Eleanor set her cup down beside the plate. "Mariah. Do you think your father's death was an accident?"
The question went through her like a change of temperature. Her chin came up, trembled once, and steadied.
"I believe my father drowned in the worst flood this county has ever seen. I believe my uncle has put flowers on that grave every April for thirty years, because the family plot is his to keep, and he keeps it." She pulled in a breath. "Please. Let my father rest."
"I'm not asking anyone to open a grave. I'm asking why a line moved on paper."
"Because the creek moved." Mariah stood and gathered her coat. "I've said what I came to say. You were always the most exact person in this town, Eleanor Vance. That's why people ask you to survey their land and not their lives."
At the door she stopped. "Keep the plate. It was my grandmother's, and she'd want it in a house where somebody actually cooks."
The white sedan backed out of the drive and turned left, toward Old Mill Road. Eleanor stood at the screen door until the sound of it had gone.
She carried the plate to the sink and ran cold water over her hands. Mariah had told the truth as she understood it; that was plain enough. She believed the flood had taken her father, and she believed her uncle had spent thirty years keeping a grief that was not his. Every paper that mattered in the years afterward had passed through Silas Blackwood's hands, and no one had ever given her a reason to ask for any of them back.
Mariah was not a suspect. She was a route, and her uncle was driving.
The phone rang at eleven.
"Eleanor? It's Grace Miller. I hope I'm not disturbing you."
"You're not."
"I believe you should know something. Mrs. Cates telephoned the history room this morning, before she came to you. She asked what materials you'd requested."
"Did you tell her?"
"I told her I'd have to check the log." A pause. "That isn't a lie, exactly. It just isn't the whole truth, and I don't like the way that sits."
"Thank you, Grace."
"If I may — I could keep your requests in my own notebook for a while. Just until you decide what you're doing."
"Write them down anyway. In your own hand, with the dates. I want there to be a record."
When Grace hung up, Eleanor cleared the kitchen table and unrolled both maps, the 1993 linen copy and the 1995 revision, weighting the corners with the sugar bowl and a can of beans. Fifty acres sat between them like a room with the door taken off.
She put her finger on the bridge. Old Mill Creek sat on a road the county had closed to traffic in 1988, with Blackwood land on both banks and nothing at the far end worth reaching. Thomas had gone out that night with the paved road under water and the worst storm in a hundred years coming down the mountain. Nobody walked to a dead bridge in a flood to clear debris.
The question was not why Thomas Blackwood went to the bridge. The question was where the firemen found him, and who was standing on the bank when they did.
She picked up the phone and dialed the number next door.
"Brady."
"Dr. Brady? It's Eleanor Vance. I need to ask you about the Old Mill Creek Bridge."
Comments
Loading the conversation…